Sh Uthaymeen explains the hadeeth of `adwa (contagion) (Part 1)

(In the excerpt below Sh Uthaymeen explains that causes do not have an effect in and of themselves, but only do so by the permission and decree of Allah).

From Kitab-ut-Tawhid (Regarding the prohibition of believing in bad omens):

Abu Hurairah radiyAllaahu `anhu said that Allaah’s Messenger sallAllaahu’alaihiwasallam said:

There is no `adwa (contagion), nor tiyarah, nor haamah (types of bad omens related to birds), nor safar (reading bad omens into the month of Safar)

Reported by Bukhari and Muslim.

 

Sh Uthaymeen said in his commentary:

The words of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) “There is no ‘adwa” are general in meaning, thus the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) states that there is no contagion (without the permission of Allaah).

‘Adwa (contagion) refers to the spread of a disease from a sick person to a healthy one. What happens in the case of physical diseases may also happen in the case of psychological diseases. Hence the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said that a bad companion is the like one who operates the bellows: Either he will burn your clothes, or you will notice a bad smell from him.

The words “there is no ‘adwa” include both physical and psychological diseases, even though it is more apparent with regard to physical disease.

The words “no tiyarah (lit. superstitious belief in bird omens)” refers to feeling superstitious because of something that you see, hear or know.

With regard to the words “no haamah”, haamah is interpreted in two ways:

1 – That it is a bird similar to an owl, or an owl. The Arabs believed that if a person was killed, his bones became a haamah that could fly and shriek until he was avenged. Some of them believed that the haamah was the soul of the slain person.

2 – Some of the Arabs said that the haamah was a particular bird, which they regarded as a bad omen. If it landed on the house of one of them and made a sound, they said that it was predicting a death. They believed that this was a sign that that person would die soon. All of these are undoubtedly false beliefs.

The words “No Safar” refers to the month of Safar, which the Arabs used to regard as inauspicious, especially for marriage.

And it was said that it was a stomach disease that affected camels and was transmitted from one camel to another; based on this, mentioning it after ‘adwa (contagion) comes under the heading of mentioning something specific after something general.

It is more likely that what is meant by Safar here is the month, and that what is meant by saying “No Safar” is that it is not to be regarded as inauspicious, rather it is like any other time, during which good or bad things may be decreed.

This does not mean that these things do not happen, because they do happen. Rather it is a statement that they do not have any effect. The One Who causes things to happen is Allaah. If any of these things has a known effect then that is valid and real; if any of them is imagined to have an effect, then that is invalid and false. Thus the hadeeth demonstrates that if there is a valid effect, it cannot be attributed to that thing itself (rather the One Who causes it to happen is Allaah). If the effect is merely imagined, then this hadeeth is stating that it has no effect in the first place.

Reopening Primary Schools during the Pandemic

From the New England Journal of Medicine (free access):

https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMms2024920

Sh Fawzan and Germ Theory

Q:

Some people use a type of incense called “al-Bakhur ul-Jawi” and they say that it kills germs and disinfects the house particularly when diseases are spreading, so is this permissible?

A:

One should ask the medical doctors about this – does this incense have the property of killing germs, as you said – cleaning the house – (if so then) there is no problem with this as it is from utilizing the means. We have been commanded to utilize the means which contain benefit. However, if this is just a claim which is not based on evidence and is not established, then this is not permissible.  

[54:54 onwards]
 


Comment:
 
Note that some very odd claims (that germs allegedly don’t exist or that they don’t cause disease etc.) are being spread on messaging apps and social media. No appropriately trained medical doctors whether Muslim or non-Muslim hold this position.

Looking at Sh Fawzan’s statement there are a number of points which can be made:

  • The Shaikh directs the questioner to ask the medical doctors about this matter (as they are appropriately qualified to discuss such issues).
  • He does not deny the existence of germs nor try to claim that they are irrelevant when it comes to the spread of disease.
  • He says that we should utilize means which bring about benefit (e.g. cleaning and sterilizing areas to prevent infection – if these means of cleaning are effective).
  • If someone claims that a certain means has benefit then the claim on its own is not enough, rather it should be established, based upon evidence.
  • If something has not been proven to work then one should not utilize this means.

Please note the approach of the Shaikh, indeed of the Shuyookh in general in the Muslim lands, and please beware of unqualified people making wild claims about medical matters without referring to Muslim doctors or to the scholars. Spreading medical misinformation is speaking without knowledge and causes harm and may even lead to people dying wal`iyaadhubillaah. May Allaah protect the lives and health of our Muslim brothers and sisters.


 
Dr Adnaan Ali
MBBChir (medical doctor)

The pioneering surgeons who cleaned up filthy hospitals

https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200812-the-pioneering-surgeons-who-cleaned-up-filthy-hospitals

How surgeons learned to operate on beating hearts

https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200708-how-surgeons-learned-to-operate-on-beating-hearts

How agonising surgery paved the way for anaesthetics

https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200624-how-agonising-surgery-paved-the-way-for-anaesthetics

How intensive care units were born

https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200610-how-intensive-care-units-were-born